When Can a Car Owner Be Liable for a Crash Someone Else Causes in Illinois?
The person driving a car at the time of a crash is not always the person who owns it. When the driver borrowed the car, the circumstances under which the owner let them use it might affect who is responsible for the injuries.
In Illinois, a car owner can be liable for lending a vehicle to someone they knew or should have known was unsafe to drive. The risk that made it unsafe to lend the car must also have contributed to the crash. If you were injured in a car accident in 2026, our Chicago, IL car accident attorney will help you determine who should be held responsible.
When Does Lending a Car Make the Owner Liable for an Accident in Illinois?
A car owner can be liable if they let someone use the car despite knowing, or having reason to know, that the person was likely to drive unsafely. Illinois courts call this negligent entrustment. The claim focuses on the owner’s decision to lend the car and how that decision contributed to the injuries.
How Does Control of the Car Affect an Owner’s Liability for an Accident in Illinois?
For a negligent entrustment claim, the owner must have had the right to decide whether the driver could use the car. A name on the title does not settle that question. If two people own the car, the court looks at whether one had the right to control the other’s use of it.
If the owner controlled who could drive, the next question is whether they gave permission. They could give it directly by handing over the keys for a trip or imply it by regularly letting the driver borrow the car without asking. Having access to the keys alone does not show that the owner agreed to let the person drive.
In Zedella v. Gibson, a father co-signed his adult son’s car loan and was listed as a co-owner. The son kept the car at his own home and used it as his own. The Illinois Supreme Court found that the father did not have the right to control his son’s use of the car. Helping his son buy it did not make him liable for the crash.
What Must a Car Owner Know About an Unsafe Driver to Be Liable for a Crash in Illinois?
A negligent entrustment claim requires showing that the owner knew or should have known the person was unsafe to drive before letting them use the car. The driver’s condition at the time and what the owner knew about their driving history help establish that knowledge. Relevant circumstances include:
- Visible signs of alcohol or drug impairment
- A suspended or revoked driver’s license
- Repeated reckless driving the owner witnessed or knew about
- A medical restriction that barred the person from driving
- A lack of experience handling the type of vehicle being borrowed
Illinois law also prohibits knowingly allowing an unauthorized driver to take a vehicle onto a highway under 625 ILCS 5/6-304. However, a license problem alone does not explain what caused the crash. You must still connect the risk the owner knew or should have recognized to the driving that caused your injuries.
Can a Car Owner’s Insurance Cover a Crash Even if Someone Else Was Driving Their Car?
The owner’s auto liability policy can cover a borrower who had permission to use the car, even if the owner did nothing wrong. Illinois law addresses coverage for drivers with express or implied permission under 625 ILCS 5/7-317. The insurer’s obligation to cover the driver is separate from whether the owner is personally liable.
For example, an owner could lend a car to a licensed friend with a safe driving record. If the friend causes a crash by failing to yield, the owner’s policy could cover the friend’s liability even though there was no reason for the owner to refuse the loan. An attorney will review which policies apply before you accept a settlement.
Contact a Chicago, IL Car Accident Lawyer
A crash involving a borrowed car can leave you unsure whose insurance to contact. At Kadzai Law Group, LLC, our attorney will review who had permission to use the car and identify who should be held responsible for your injuries.
Attorney David Kadzai also serves as an arbitrator for the American Arbitration Association. To schedule a free consultation, contact our Hyde Park, IL car accident attorney or call 312-229-0050.












